Heat Pump vs Gas Boiler: Which One Should Heat Your Home Next?
Last updated:
- A funded ECO4 gas boiler is only possible until 31 December 2026
- The £7,500 heat pump grant carries on into 2027 in England and Wales
- In our price cap example, yearly running costs land within pounds
- In that example, heat pump efficiency matters more than the fuel choice
- Heat pump fitting has 0% VAT until 31 March 2027
- Homes on oil or LPG get an extra £1,500 until March 2027
Torn between a new boiler and a heat pump?
Check If You Qualify- Gas Safe registered engineers
- Company No. 16100301

31 Dec 2026
ECO4 closes
GOV.UK
£7,500
Heat pump grant
GOV.UK
26.32p per kWh
Electricity unit price
Ofgem price cap
7.97p per kWh
Gas unit price
Ofgem price cap
Heat pump vs gas boiler: what really separates them in 2026?
A gas boiler burns gas to make heat. A heat pump uses electricity to move heat from the outside air into your radiators and hot water, so it gives out more heat than the electricity it uses. That basic difference shapes everything else: what you pay to fit each one, what you pay to run it, and which grant can help.
Status, checked 12 November 2026: GOV.UK says the Energy Company Obligation scheme is closing on 31 December 2026; if you hope to get a funded gas boiler, the time left is short, while the heat pump grant carries on.
| What you are weighing up | Gas boiler | Air source heat pump |
|---|---|---|
| Fuel | Mains gas | Electricity |
| Main funding in 2026 | ECO4, for households that qualify, until 31 December 2026 | Boiler Upgrade Scheme: £7,500 off the price in England and Wales |
| Funding in 2027 | ECO4 closed | The £7,500 grant continues; the extra £1,500 for oil and LPG homes runs until March 2027 |
| VAT on fitting | Standard rate for a conventional boiler system; reduced rate possible if grant-funded | 0% until 31 March 2027, then 5% |
| Unit price at the Oct to Dec 2026 cap | 7.97p per kWh of gas | 26.32p per kWh of electricity |
| How the heat feels | Radiators heat up fast and run hot | Radiators run cooler for longer |
| Space needed | Boiler on a wall, often no cylinder with a combi | Outdoor unit, usually a hot water cylinder indoors |
How daily life changes when a heat pump replaces a combi is set out in our guide to the air source heat pump. This page stays on the air source heat pump vs gas boiler head-to-head. Other differences show up in the house itself: GOV.UK's Heat and Buildings Strategy puts the lifetime of a natural gas boiler at around 15 years, while Energy Saving Trust says a heat pump itself is likely to last 20 years or more. Energy Saving Trust also says a boiler typically runs its water at 75°C and a heat pump at around 45°C, which is why heat pump radiators often need to be bigger, and that a heat pump installation itself typically takes around three days.
What does each one cost to put in once grants are counted?
In a heat pump vs gas boiler cost comparison, a gas boiler can cost the least upfront of any option for a household that qualifies for ECO4, because the scheme pays for the approved work. With us, where a household qualifies, ECO4 pays for the work, and any shortfall is quoted in writing before work starts. ECO4 has strict boiler rules, covered on our ECO4 scheme page, so a survey decides what a home can have.
A heat pump starts from a higher price, then the grant comes off it. GOV.UK lists £7,500 towards an air source heat pump under the Boiler Upgrade Scheme. Energy Saving Trust's typical air source heat pump installation cost is around £12,000 before the grant, and its research assumes around £3,700 on average to replace a gas boiler when it fails. Our guide to air source heat pump cost shows typical installed prices before and after that £7,500.
One detail catches people out when they put two quotes next to each other. HMRC's VAT notice 708/6 zero-rates heat pump installations until 31 March 2027, but treats a central heating system built around a conventional boiler as a standard-rated supply, though the reduced rate may apply if it is grant-funded. So a privately paid boiler quote may carry the standard rate of VAT while the heat pump quote carries none. Check the VAT line on both before you compare totals.
Which costs less to run at today's price cap?
On heat pump vs gas boiler UK running costs, the two can come out almost level over a year at the Ofgem price cap for 1 October to 31 December 2026. Which one wins depends far more on how efficiently the heat pump runs than on the price of either fuel.
The two unit prices behind every sum below are 26.32p per kWh for electricity and 7.97p per kWh for gas: the average Direct Debit rates in Ofgem's price cap for England, Scotland and Wales. Electricity costs about 3.3 times as much as gas per unit, so a heat pump needs to make more than 3.3 units of heat from each unit of electricity to beat the gas itself; because a boiler loses some heat, the real break-even is a seasonal efficiency (SCOP) of about 3. Energy Saving Trust says heat pumps tend to run with a seasonal performance factor (SPF) of 3.1.
Example (illustrative only): take a home that needs 10,000 kWh of heat a year. That heat demand is a round number chosen for the sum, not a typical or official figure. The two efficiencies below are assumptions, not facts about any product.
- Gas boiler, assumed 90% efficient: about 11,111 kWh of gas, so about £886 a year.
- Heat pump, assumed seasonal efficiency (SCOP) of 3: about 3,333 kWh of electricity, so about £877 a year.
- The same heat pump at an assumed SCOP of 2.5: about £1,053 a year.
- The same heat pump at an assumed SCOP of 3.5: about £752 a year.
In this example, the gap between a poorly set up heat pump and a well set up one, about £300 a year, is far bigger than the gap between the heat pump and the boiler. For the cost of running a heat pump vs gas boiler, design, radiator sizing and controls matter more than the badge on the unit. The same sums work for a heat pump vs combi boiler running cost check, since a combi is a gas boiler. The sums leave out standing charges; what happens to those when you leave gas behind is covered in our guide to whether heat pumps are worth it.
Two things to keep in mind with these figures:
- Ofgem's figures include 5% VAT on gas, and there is no VAT on electricity from 1 October 2026 to 31 March 2027. Ofgem says costs cannot be compared directly to previous periods because of this change.
- These rates apply only to October to December 2026, and your own tariff may differ, so swap in the unit rates on your bill. Standard-rate sums also leave out heat pump time-of-use tariffs; Energy Saving Trust says that by switching to one a heat pump can cost less to run than a gas boiler.
When does a funded gas boiler make more sense?
A new gas boiler is usually the sensible choice when ECO4 can pay for it and the work can be finished before the scheme closes. It is also the simpler swap in homes where a heat pump would need a lot of other work first.
- Your household qualifies for ECO4 now. A qualifying benefit, plus the home's energy rating, can open the door. Our ECO4 eligibility page sets out who fits.
- There is nowhere for a hot water cylinder. A combi boiler needs no cylinder; most heat pump systems do.
- Insulation is a long way off. In a draughty, uninsulated house the heat pump quote grows to cover a larger unit and larger radiators, while a like-for-like boiler swap stays simple.
When does a heat pump beat a new boiler?
A heat pump comes out ahead of a boiler mainly when ECO4 is out of reach and the household would otherwise pay for a new boiler itself. Of the two, it is the only one with a national grant still running in 2027.
- You own the home in England or Wales. GOV.UK says you must own the property to get the £7,500 grant, and the Boiler Upgrade Scheme page explains who can claim.
- You heat with oil or LPG and have no mains gas. GOV.UK adds £1,500 to the grant until March 2027 for these homes, and our oil boiler replacement grant guide compares the routes.
- The loft and walls are insulated, or will be. A home that holds its warmth lets the heat pump work gently, so its seasonal efficiency stays high.
- You are ready to stop heating with gas. A hybrid that keeps a gas boiler for heating alongside the heat pump cannot get the grant, as our hybrid heat pump guide explains.
- You want to spread the cost. Our heat pump finance guide covers the options.
What funding is left for each in 2026 and 2027?
Timing is where the two routes split. A boiler job funded by ECO4 has to be surveyed, approved and fitted before the scheme closes, while a heat pump decision can wait into 2027 without losing the main grant.
- Before ECO4 closes: a qualifying household that wants a funded boiler should start now, because the survey and the paperwork both take time before work can be booked. Our ECO4 extension page explains how the end date was set.
- From 1 January 2027: ECO4 is closed, so it can no longer pay for a new boiler. Households on a lower income in England have a second heat pump route besides the main grant, the Warm Homes: Local Grant, which has its own income and property rules.
- After March 2027: oil and LPG homes lose the extra £1,500, and from 1 April 2027 HMRC says heat pump fitting moves to the reduced VAT rate of 5%, so the same job costs a little more.
In Scotland, the picture is different. GOV.UK says the Boiler Upgrade Scheme is open to people in England and Wales, so Scottish homes need other help for a heat pump. Our page on boiler grants in Scotland covers what is available there.
Not sure which way your home leans?
FreeBoilerUpgrade.uk fits funded gas boilers under ECO4 and also offers air source heat pumps across England and Scotland, with Boiler Upgrade Scheme help for homes in England. Because both are on the table, the heat pump vs boiler question is settled by the survey of your home and your eligibility, not by which one there is to sell.
- Tell us the basics. Your household, the home and the heating you have now.
- Compare on site. The survey looks at the radiators, the insulation and the room for a cylinder or an outdoor unit.
- Confirm the funding. Any scheme or grant sign-off is in place before work starts.
- Fit it. Boilers are fitted by a Gas Safe registered engineer, typically in 1 to 2 days on site once approved.
You see any extra cost in writing before it is added.
FAQs
Should I replace my boiler or get a heat pump?
If your household qualifies for ECO4, look at that first, because it closes on 31 December 2026 and can pay for the work. If it does not, and you own the home in England or Wales, a heat pump with the £7,500 grant is worth pricing before you pay for a new boiler yourself. A survey shows which one your home can take without major extra work.
Why is my bill so high with a heat pump?
Usually because it is running at a lower efficiency than it was designed for. The first setting to look at is the flow temperature: water sent round the radiators hotter than the design needs makes the heat pump work harder for every unit of heat. Then compare the electricity unit rate on your tariff with the price cap.
Is it okay for a heat pump to run all night in winter?
Yes. Heat pumps are designed to run for long periods at low output, and keeping the house at a steady temperature overnight is normal.
Is a heat pump cheaper to run than a gas heater?
Only once its efficiency outweighs the price gap. At the October to December 2026 cap, a heat pump needs a seasonal efficiency of about 3 just to match a 90% efficient gas boiler on unit costs. Above that it is cheaper to run; below it, gas wins.
Check If You Qualify
Four quick steps. Tap your answers and we'll do the rest.
Sources
- Ofgem: Energy price cap unit rates and standing charges
- HMRC: VAT on energy-saving materials and heating equipment (Notice 708/6)
- GOV.UK: Apply for the Boiler Upgrade Scheme (overview, what you can get, check if you're eligible)
- GOV.UK: Help from your energy supplier
- the Energy Company Obligation
- GOV.UK: Heat and Buildings Strategy
- Energy Saving Trust: heat pump guide
- Energy Saving Trust: air source heat pumps
- Energy Saving Trust: how to make renewable technology more affordable
- Energy Saving Trust: heat pump installation guide
- Energy Saving Trust: the most efficient way to run a heat pump (all checked 12 November 2026)
About This Page
FreeBoilerUpgrade.uk is an installer run by Reliant Energy Solutions Ltd (No. 16100301), incorporated on 25 November 2024. Every boiler is fitted by a Gas Safe registered engineer. We are not part of the government or Ofgem.
- Company: Reliant Energy Solutions Ltd, company number 16100301, address 16 Suite, Turner Business Centre, Middleton, Manchester M24 1RU
- Phone: 07599 995537
- Email: info@freeboilerupgrade.uk
Ready to find out which one suits your home?
Ready to Start Saving?
See if your household qualifies for funded ECO4 heating upgrades through the ECO4 scheme.
- 100%
- Free Service
- 60s
- Application
- ECO4
- Eligibility check

